Bernardo M. Villegas
Articles  >> more topics
Dreaming for the 2030 World Cup (Part 2)

 Similar to the case of Morocco, Cape Verde can provide important lessons for the Philippines in developing a strong football culture. Despite the almost impossible task of displacing basketball as the national sport, we have to do everything possible to make football the leading grassroots sport, especially in the countryside among the lower-income households. Developing football in such elite schools like Ateneo, La Salle, and even U.P. will lead nowhere because, with a few exceptions, graduates of these educational institutions will ordinarily not consider playing professional football as part of their career plans. Cape Verde made football the country’s most popular sport. Children play everywhere—in schools, neighborhoods, beaches, and small community pitches. Never mind if the children are taught first to play futsal, which can be played literally anywhere. By the time the talented players enter organized football, they have already developed excellent technical skills equally applicable to football. The country can simply encourage children to play football in schools, parks, barangays, alongside basketball.

It is wise to invest in coaches before investing in stadia or equivalent physical facilities. Cape Verde has relatively modest football facilities, but it invested in qualified coaches who teach proper technique and tactics. Countries that develop many well-trained youth coaches generally produce better players than those that focus mainly on building large stadiums. To be realistic, the task of producing youth coaches should be in the hands of business, civil society, private schools and church communities (especially Catholic parish-based) since the Philippine Government has more than enough to do in improving governance, eradicating poverty and investing in quality public education. Unfortunately, our government—whether at the national or local levels—suffer from comparison with the governments of Morocco and Cape Verde in terms of effectiveness and good governance.

Like Morocco, Cape Verde knew how to harness its diaspora, which suffers from comparison to our more than 10 million OFWs. Many of the national team players were born or trained in Portugal, France, the Netherlands, and other European countries. The football federation actively recruited these players and inspired them to represent the country of their parents or grandparents. We have done this, as in the case of the Younghusband brothers. We have done it even more in the case of the National Women’s Football team called the Filipinas that has already qualified for the Women’s World Cup two times. But we can do much more. We have an even larger overseas community. Many young Filipinos in Europe, North America, Australia and Japan are training in professional academies. Systematically identifying and inviting them to represent the Philippines could significantly strengthen our national team. As an example from my own personal experience, when I was a Visiting Professor in one of the world’s leading business schools, the IESE Business School in Barcelona, Spain, I learned of a district called Raval where there is a concentration of Filipino immigrants whose sons are being coached in the game of football, thanks to initiatives of both NGOs and the Catholic parish. We can send scouts to various cities in Europe where there are similar programs for the children of Filipino immigrants.

We can follow the example of Cape Verde in building a clear football identity.  This small African country is known for excellent defensive organization, quick counterattacks, high work rate, and strong team spirit. Every player understands the team’s style of play. I can surmise that those Filipino youth being trained in that district of Raval are being exposed to the style of play of FC Barcelona, the Spanish League champion during the last two seasons (to the dismay of Real Madrid despite their having paid a very high price for Mbappe). That style of play was described by famous football commentator, Simon Kuper, in his column in the Financial Times as “the best defense is possession” which was very obvious in the final match against Argentina in which the GOAT, my football idol Lionel Messi, was completely neutralized. I was sad to see him following the example of his team mates in acting as poor losers during the awarding ceremonies.

One major reason why Cape Verde has succeeded is that its football federation has been relatively stable and professionally managed. Long-term planning has been more important than short-term changes. It is in this regard that I will try to mobilize experts in long-term strategic planning in the private corporate sector to help all the stakeholders of the sport in formulating a long-term strategic plan beyond just targeting to qualify for the 2030 World Cup. The main components of this strategic plan will be the following characteristics shared by Morocco, Cape Verde and Croatia (another small nation that has a world-class football team): a nationwide football culture; excellent youth coaching; competent, long-term football administration; and strong pathways from youth to professional leagues. These factors matter more than population size alone. For the Philippines, building these foundations over the next two decades would likely have a greater impact than any single high-profile coach or short-term investment.

If we need decades to produce a world-class national men’s football team, why are we setting a short-term target of qualifying the 2030 World Cup, merely four years from now? Because we are not starting from scratch. Although football in the Philippines still faces certain significant structural and cultural challenges, the sport has made progress in organization, youth development, and women’s football over at least the last ten years. Over the last decade or so, the country’s state of football has gathered the following major strengths:

-The Philippine Football Federation (PFF) has shifted its focus toward long-term player development rather than relying primarily on overseas-based Filipino players. It has expanded youth academies, talent identification, and regional competitions.

-Grassroots football is growing through programs such as FIFA Football for Schools, Centers of Excellence, and regional youth championship for U16 and U19 players. These initiatives are reaching more children throughout the whole Archipelago.   

-The domestic Philippines Football League has become more stable than in previous years and now provides regular competition for around 275 professional and semi-professional players.

-Women’s football, including in the University of Asia and the Pacific where I teach, has become one the country’s biggest success stories. The national women’s team (the Filipinas) qualified for both the 2023 and 2027 FIFA Women’s World Cup, inspiring many young girls to take up the sport.

In the SWOT analysis, however, the following weaknesses stand out:

-Football is not a mainstream sport. Basketball overwhelmingly dominates public interest, media coverage, and business sponsorship.

-Too few football fields. Many schools lack proper pitches, and football competes with other sports for facilities, especially in the case of futsal. The exception in the Metro Manila area is the PAREF Southridge School for boys which has an ultra-modern football field that many clubs actually rent. The football team of Southridge, together with another high school—Claret--, are allowed to play in the UAAP league which is for university football teams.

-Weak professional ecosystem. The PFL is improving but still has relatively few clubs, modest attendance, and limited commercial revenue compared with leagues in Thailand and Vietnam.

-Dependence on overseas Filipinos. Although this is also the case, as we saw above, with Cape Verde, Morocco, and Croatia who have done well in the World Cup by relying on overseas talents, the Philippines with a population of close to 120 million whose average age is 26, should be able to develop more local talents, without neglecting to consider those who are overseas. To be continued.